Les 5 du Vin

5 journalistes parlent du vin

A companion or a bible?

3 Commentaires

Karen MacNel



Following last week’s post on the new edition of The Wine Bible’s coverage of the Loire, David Cobbold asked me to do a comparison with the new edition – the fourth – of The Oxford Companion to Wine. As always I do what I am told ……

Firstly there are some similarities: both are edited by women: The Wine Bible by Karen MacNeill and The Oxford Companion by Jancis Robinson MW. Both women sport impressive items of jewellery – a necklace for Jancis and earrings for Karen. The rather severe photo of Jancis appears to be warning reviewers to watch out or else……

Both book covers make big claims. The Bible is ‘ A masterpiece of wine writing’ while The Companion is ‘The greatest wine book ever published’, so clearly we have heavyweight titles here…..

Talking of actual weight The Bible at 1.34 kilos is a flyweight compared to The Companion, which tips the scales at 2.85 kilos. Bearing in mind that Jancis’ Wine Grapes is even heavier @ 3.08 kilos, it is clear that her campaign against over-heavy wine bottles does not extend to wine books!

The Wine Bible runs to 996 pages for $24.95 against 860 pages for $65 forThe Companion. These figures are, however, misleading as The Companion is very significantly wider than The Bible with three columns of text compared a biblical two. There are black and white photos or tables on many of The Bible’s pages, whereas The Companion is solid text with the few full pages colour photos are not included in the page count. Although I haven’t attempted a word count it is clear that Jancis uses many more words than Karen.

So how do the two contestants fare regarding the Loire? As we saw last week The Bible is weak on the Loire with a decidedly partial revision. UnlikeThe Bible, which is arranged by region,The Companion is ordered alphabetically, which makes it rather more difficult to judge as it involves hopping about the book.

Anyway time for a look at some of The Companion’s Loire entries. Montlouis is covered in more detail and includes mention of the recent AC Montlouis Pétillant Naturel. However, Montlouis’ recent dynamism isn’t recognised and the figure of a third of the production being sparkling is low – the Interloire site has sparkling wine at 55%.

Turning to Vouvray the entry declares that ‘In less generous vintages, only dry and possibly sparkling wines are made.’ Whereas sparkling Vouvray is invariably made, especially in difficult vintages as there is both a demand for it in French supermarkets and the maximum yield permitted for sparkling Vouvray is substantially higher than that for still – 65 hl/ha compared with 52 hl/ha for still.

The Quarts de Chaume entry makes me think that The Companion lacks the local knowledge that would provide full accuracy. It is incorrect to say there has been little recent investment as there has been investment at Bellerive and, perhaps, more importantly the last decade or more has seen a significant number of Anjou producers acquiring parcels here. Domaine Ogereau being the latest. The situation is now radically different from the late 1960s when there were just a handful of producers. It is also incorrect to say that the minimum sugar levels are rarely achieved. Of recent vintages since 2005 only in the horrendous October 2012 was it virtually impossible to make genuine Quarts de Chaume – unless you picked unripe and used cryoextraction……

Would I buy either of these reference books? Fortunately these were both review copies. I certainly wouldn’t buy Karen MacNeill’s Bible and I would have to think hard before I shelled out £40 (£25.03 on Amazon…) for Jancis Robinson’s Companion, although I am pretty sure there are sections that are more convincing than the Loire.

My doubts about buying The Companion are, in part, whether I would actually use it as if I have a query the net is my first resource. I have had my copy of The Companion for a while now and have hardly used it …..


Auteur : Les 5 du Vin

Journalistes en vin

3 réflexions sur “A companion or a bible?

  1. Thanks, Jim, for your forthright and honest comparison of these two books. If I was either of their authors, I would be contacting you to help update the Loire wine region sections in future editions.

    Aimé par 1 personne

  2. You offer us a review which is as naughty as mine would have been, only in gentler words. You are a well educated Anglo-saxon, no Germano-celtic brute without heart nor polish. But the facts remain: who cares about such books in an era where one click of the mouse delivers this type of information ? Of course, being “a man of the web”, you may be biased. But I think not. “Wine Grapes” by the same Jancis is another kettle of fish altogether, doesn’t serve the same purpose. I’ve been offered it as a birthday present and am pleased to exhibit it on my bookshelf, next to Das Kapital, Die Protestantische Ethik und der Geist des Kapitalismus, Harry Potter, La Divina Commedia and Never Send Flowers (who knows this one?). All this is perfectly true, nota bene. And Mrs Robinson was kind enough to ship me an adhesive dedication to top the bill. So I should definitely not “hide it in a hiding place where no one ever goes” … (hey hey hey).

    Aimé par 1 personne

  3. I think Tom is quite right.


Laisser un commentaire

Entrez vos coordonnées ci-dessous ou cliquez sur une icône pour vous connecter:

Logo WordPress.com

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte WordPress.com. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Photo Google+

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte Google+. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Image Twitter

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte Twitter. Déconnexion /  Changer )

Photo Facebook

Vous commentez à l'aide de votre compte Facebook. Déconnexion /  Changer )


Connexion à %s